Famous existential psychotherapist Irvin Yalom suggested that death anxiety is one of the major forces that operates in our psyche, often without much awareness. In his analysis, there are two categories of maladaptive, neurotic responses to this anxiety. One of them has a significant political implication that was out of scope of Yalom’s work but can be important for us to consider.
He named this response ‘the ultimate rescuer’, an omnipotent force that can provide defense against the immensity of death:
“Human beings, for millenniums, have conquered their fear of death in this manner and have chosen to lay down their freedom, indeed their lives, for the embrace of some higher figure or personified cause.”
Historically, people have believed that a deity or a church/religion, as its earthly representative, can serve as ultimate rescuer. Most religions confer a promise of a cozy afterlife in exchange for following a certain prescribed set of rules. Belief in an ultimate saviour while subjecting oneself to its grace is a way of putting something between ourselves and the enormity of the existential axiom that we are going to die.
The ultimate rescuer serves as a shield from death anxiety. It’s as if the reality itself is too much for us to handle, and it’s easier to deal with it based on what the ultimate rescuer’s representatives will tell us. Consequently, we give up our agency and freedom. We trade our agency for an ephemeral deliverance. Our thinking is reduced and our wants are reduced because the ultimate saviour prescribes the right things we should think and want in order to fulfill our part of the deal with the rescuer, as the logic goes.
No longer can we be the captain of our own ship—the journey is too dangerous and we must give away control to a higher, omnipotent and benevolent force. Of course, the irony is that the deal was never signed by the other party. Still, we start delivering on our part of it.
As times have changed and many people have forgone religion, the void hasn’t remained empty. The “dizziness of freedom”, as Danish existential philosopher Søren Kirkegaard aptly called it, was lulled, for the majority, by recasting the role of ultimate saviour to the state.
Even though the state doesn’t promise a paradisiacal afterlife, psychologically it has assumed a similar role: that of an ultimate rescuer from the worldly troubles that can feel overwhelming. It offers a deal to protect us from a tumultuous, chaotic world that would otherwise descend into the horrors of Hobbesian war of all against all. For that, we need to follow the rules imposed on us and give away a significant chunk of our income. But more importantly, we need to subject our lives to the leadership of political elites.
The psychological need for safety is real. The enormity of the world’s complexity is real. The ineffable mystery of death is real. But we can heed this existential challenge in profoundly different ways: either by acknowledging our limitations as humans as irreducible and facing them with courage and humility, or fumbling in denial, trying to build a protective wall around ourselves, only to surrender our freedoms in the process. One is a mature response, the other is infantile.
As children, we are small and weak and must rely on adults. As we grow up and mature, we need to break these bonds. The state tries, and often succeeds, to take the place of the parental archetype. When we allow that to happen, we remain in our psychological childhood, isolated from the existential contact with reality.
What does this mean for us?
Lots of libertarian and classical liberal arguments try to persuade people of the moral or utilitarian value of social and economic freedom, but many of us fail to see how the gravity that attracts people to statism is rooted in existential anxieties. Unless these anxieties are acknowledged, most people are not capable of hearing us out. They will become defensive, irrational, and closed-minded.
We need to be aware that what we are offering is a bitter pill—the world out there is messy and unpredictable. Meeting it requires us to take risks, accept responsibility, and act with courage. Resistance to taking this pill is natural—it’s natural to want to feel safe, protected, and secure about one’s future. But the task of creating meaning, navigating uncertainty, and taking responsibility for our lives cannot be delegated to the state, the church, or anyone else. It is our own life’s task.